
*sigh, here we go again, mangled saffrican accents, foreign filmmakers who've convinced themselves that they're ooh so plugged into the south african zeitgeist. all of which yields the mess that is "disgrace". the screenwriters even had the odasity to change the ending of the book to suit a movie audience. kak kak and kak again. the film is ostensibly set in eastern cape, err err bar the fucking view of table mountain and surrounds, clearly this movie wasn't made with locals in mind. clearly. we here at absoulute always get nervous when we hear of these semi-big-budget Hollywood flicks with their household name big amerikana movie stars. we know two things for sure, they'll sound more welsh than they do saffarican and the producers are cowards.

there is something fundamentally, let's repeat that, fundamentally inauthentic about this flick, as we said, it tries to pass of eastern cape as the western cape, it has john malkovich really trying is damnest to pull of the wretched sounds of the saffrican white middle class post apartheid experience (err err...don't where going with that description but it fits). he tries, lawd knows he tries and i guess if you're from mars you might even find him convincing.

this was always going to be a difficult movie to pull off, very. the book had this steady pace that never let up, never too fast but nonetheless quick enough for you to want to put it down and catch your breath. this movie is too deliberate, it tries too hard to consider all the important narratives, too busy making sure that the audience d.o.e.s n.o.t m.i.s.s all the all too important social commentary. for all its faults district 9 got one thing right, at certain fundamental glimpses it was unmistakenbly south african. detail was afforded to that small fact, that d9 was set in south africa with an overwhelmingly south african narrative. disgrace on the hand didnt even bother, detail? what detail? coetzee should be ashamed that he gave his blessings for this movie. it foks up the idea we have of coetzee as this genius recluse, intolerant of all things bullshit. he might as well have let the screenwriters, the casting director and director all have their way with his wife, his second wife at that. in case its not clear from the above, we were not impressed





























